Tuberculosis and literature in Córdoba in the first half of the 20th century
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53872/2422.7544.n5.9896Abstract
In this paper we intend to continue and deepen the research initiated, based on literature that has not yet been analyzed and trying to give new directions to the one already studied. We will try to investigate about the community of images that circulated in the Argentine society and that were reflected in the literature, however these images had different interpretations and discursive charges according to the positioning and the role of the social actor in relation to the disease: the sick, the doctor and the healthy. For the analysis we will take only the literature that emphasizes the life of the sick person in the sierras of Córdoba, where the images generated about the tuberculosis sufferer are visualized to a greater extent. In order to carry out the study, we have a wide range of literature: The memoirs of Antonio Cetrángolo, a physiologist, published under the title Thirty Years caring for tuberculosis patients; Esther, a story published in several issues in the newspaper Los Principios of the city of Córdoba, whose author was the Catholic physician Juan Cafferata, a scholar of the tuberculosis problem in the city of Córdoba; Ester Primavera, a short story by Roberto Arlt written in the thirties and published in El jorobadito; Balcón hacia la muerte, an autobiographical novel written by Ulises Pettit de Murat and Boquitas pintadas, a novel by Manuel Puig. It is not important here the quality of the literary work or the current to which each one belonged, but the fact that tuberculosis has been the guiding thread on which each of the texts is mounted. What we intend is to visualize and analyze images of tuberculosis in its social construction. Due to the extension of the work, we will take only some aspects for the analysis: first, we will present the importance of the Córdoba sierras for the climatic cure and medical testimonies about the arrival of tuberculosis patients to the region during the first half of the 20th century. Secondly, we will analyze some of the images that circulated in the Argentinean society at the beginning and middle of the 20th century and were reflected in the mentioned texts. Finally, we will study three topics that we consider important in the perception that both doctors and patients had of the disease: the idea of the landscape, the problem of contagion and daily life in the sanatoriums.
References
Armus, Diego. 2000 “Tango Gender and tuberculosis in Buenos Aires, 1900-1940”. En
Armus, Diego (Editor) From cholera to AIDS. History and disease in Modern Latin American. Duke University Press..
Armus, Diego, 1999 “De médicos dictadores” y “pacientes sometidos”. Los tuberculosos en acción. Argentina 1920-1940”. En Allpanchis. Instituto de pastoral andina SICUANI –Cusco 53
Armus, Diego. 2000. “La enfermedad en la historiografía de América Latina”. En Cuadernos de Historia Serie Economía y Sociedad. Area de Historia CIFFYH. UNC. Nº 3 Año.
Bernabeu Mestre, Josep. “La actualidad historiográfica dela historia social de la enfer- medad”. En Boletín de la Asociación de Demografía Histórica. VII-3. Madrid 1989
Bertolli Filho, Claudio 1992. “Doença e estigma” . En Cadernos de historia e saúde. Casa de Oswaldo Cruz Nº 2
Bialet, Massé Juan. 1985 Informe sobre el estado de las clases obreras argentinas a comienzos de siglo. Centro Editor de América Latina. Buenos Aires.
Boria, Adriana 1999. “Entre la naturaleza y la cultura: las figuras de la mujer en las fisiologías del siglo XIX”. En Forastelli Fabricio y Tiquell, Ximena (comp.) Las marcas del género. Configuraciones de la diferencia en la cultura. CEA. UNC.
Carbonetti, Adrián . “La tuberculosis en córdoba. la construcción de un espacio marginal”. En Revista Estudios en el Número 9 Julio 1997- Junio 1998. . Centro de Estudios Avanzados, Universidad Nacional de Córdoba.
Carbonetti, Adrián. “La tuberculosis en la literatura argentina tres ejemplos a través de la novela el cuento y la poesía. En História Ciencia e Saúde. Manguinhos. Vol VI Nº3 Nov. 1999-Feb-2000.
Carbonetti, Adrián. 1999 Enfermedad y sociedad . La tuberculosis en la ciudad de Córdoba. 1906-1947. Editorial de la Municipalidad de Córdoba. Córdoba
Carbonetti, Adrián. 1997 La tuberculosis en la ciudad de Córdoba. Historia sociodemográfica de una enfermedad. 1906-1947. Tesis para aspirar al grado de Magíster en Demografía. C.E.A. U.N.C. Mimeo.
Carbonetti, Adrián 2002 “Tuberculosis y medicina. Visiones medicas de una enfermedad en el cambio de siglo 1880-1930”. En Carbonetti Adrián, Blanco Fernando y Garcés Carlos. De sujetos, definiciones y fronteras. Ensayos sobre desciplinamien- to, marginación y exclusión en América. De la colonia al siglo XX. Ferreyra editores. Y UNJU. Córdoba.
Carriego, Evaristo. 1993. Poemas. Centro Editor de América Latina. Buenos Aires. Cela, Camilo José. 1993 Pabellón de reposo. Ediciones Destino. Madrid
Goffman, Ervin. 1993. Estigma. La identidad deteriorada. Amorrotru editores. Buenos Aires.
Mann, Thomas. 1988. La montaña mágica. Ediciones Orbis. Barcelona. Primera Edición. 1924.
Nicholson, Linda. 1992. “Hacia un método para comprender el género”. En Ramos Escandón, Carmen (comp.) Género e Historia. Insituto Mora. U.A.M. México.
Panisset Ornellas, Cleuza. 1997. Paciente Excluído. Historia e Crítica das Práticas Médicas de confinamiento. Editora Revan. Río de Janeiro.
Porto, Angela. “A vida inteira que podia ter sido e que nào foi: trajetoria de un poeta tísico”. História Ciència y Saúde Mnguinhos- Vol VI Nº3 Nov. 1999-Feb-2000
Sanchez, Silvia 1988. Historia de Santa María. mimeo
Sontag, Susan. 1989. La enfermedad y sus metáforas. Muchnik Editores. Barcelona.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2014 Cuadernos de historia. Serie Economía y Sociedad
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors publishing in this journal accept the following terms:
a. The author maintains their copyrights and grants this journal the publication of the first original version of their work that is subject to the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0. This license agreement allows:
Sharing — copy and redistribution of the published material by any means and formats
Reusing — remix, change, and creation of new material from the published work for any purpose, including commercial use.
b. Authors may enter other non-exclusive license agreements of distribution of the version of the published work (i.e. uploading the material on an institutional virtual archive or republishing it on a monographic volume) as long as they attribute the publication of the original version to this journal.
c. It is allowed and recommended that authors publicize their work on the Internet (i.e. on institutional virtual archives or on their personal or professional websites) after their work has been published in this journal.