Una aproximación multi-metodológica al problema de selección de equipos de trabajo
Keywords:
multi-methodologies, Soft Operational Research, multicriteria decision making, informatic developmentAbstract
The paper analyzes the problem of choosing a working group with specific roles to develop informatic projects. The problem is complex because it includes technological and social issues; its resolution requires consideration of perceptions and attitudes of many people and requirements of different organizations. Given this complexity, this document proposes a multi-methodological approach that incorporates group perspective for the analysis of necessary decision making. This approach combines Soft System Methodology with Repertory Grid, with a multi-criteria decision method for group, called Processes DRV and with Binary Programming. The approach is exemplified with a real case, it is a company that outsources computer services.
The document includes evidence that it approach contributes to reduce shocks that affecting to the group decision-making processes, thus favoring the training and commitment of involved players with the adopted decisions. In the conclusions, the paper suggests the possibility of transferring this approach to other management systems, such as environmental or quality systems.
Downloads
References
ALLES, M. A. (2002): “DESEMPEÑO POR COMPETENCIAS: EVALUACIÓN DE 360O”. Ediciones Granica SA.
ALENCAR L.; ALMEIDA A. (2010): “A MODEL FOR SELECTING PROJECT TEAM MEMBERS USING MULTICRITERIA GROUP DECISION MAKING”. Pesquisa Operacional – Vol.30 - pgs. 221-236.
ALEXANDER, P.; VAN LOGGERENBERG, J.; LOTRIET, H.; PHAHLAMOHLAKA, J. (2010): “THE USE OF THE REPERTORY GRID FOR COLLABORATION AND REFLECTION IN A RESEARCH CONTEXT”. Group Decision and Negotiation – Vol. 19 – pgs. 479-504.
ALBERTO, C.; CARIGNANO, C. (2013): “APOYO CUANTITATIVO A LAS DECISIONES”. Cuarta edición. Cooperadora Facultad de Ciencias Económicas, UNC, Argentina.
BENJAMINI, Y.; YEKUTIELI, D. (2001): “THE CONTROL OF THE FALSE DISCOVERY RATE IN MULTIPLE TESTING UNDER DEPENDENCY”. Annals of statistics – pgs. 1165-188.
CHECKLAND, P. (2000): “SOFT SYSTEMS METHODOLOGY: A THIRTY YEAR RETROSPECTIVE”. Syst Res Behav Sci – Vol.17- pgs. 11-58.
DIAS, L.; CLIMACO, J. (2005): “DEALING WITH IMPRECISE INFORMATION IN GROUP MULTICRITERIA DECISIONS: A METHODOLOGY AND A GDSS ARCHITECTURE”. European Journal of Operational Research - Vol 160 - pgs. 291-307.
FRANCO, L.; LORD, E. (2011): “UNDERSTANDING MULTI-METHODOLOGY: EVALUATING THE PERCEIVED IMPACT OF MIXING METHODS FOR GROUP BUDGETARY DECISIONS”. Omega - Vol. 39 - pgs. 362–372.
FORMAN, E.; PENIWATI, K. (1998): “AGGREGATING INDIVIDUAL JUDGMENTS AND PRIORITIES WITH THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS”. European journal of operational research – Vol. 108 – pgs. 165-169.
FU C.; YANG S. (2012): “AN EVIDENTIAL REASONING BASED CONSENSUS MODEL FOR MULTIPLE ATTRIBUTE GROUP DECISION ANALYSIS PROBLEMS WITH INTERVAL-VALUED GROUP CONSENSUS REQUIREMENTS”. European Journal of Operational Research - Vol 223 - pgs. 167–176.
GEORGIOU, I. (2006): “MANAGERIAL EFFECTIVENESS FROM A SYSTEM THEORICAL POINT OF VIEW”. Systemic Practice and Action Research – Vol. 19 – pgs. 441-459.
GEORGIOU, I. (2008): “MAKING DECISIONS IN THE ABSENCE OF CLEAR FACTS”. European Journal of Operational Research – Vol. 185 - pgs. 299-321.
GOMES, L; ZANAZZI, J. (2013): “ANÁLISIS MULTICRITERIO COM MULTIPLES DECISORES: APLICACIÓN COMBINADA DE LOS MÉTODOS TODIM Y PROCESOS DRV”. Revista de Administração do Gestor – Vol 2 - pgs. 105-136.
JIN-LING, X. (2009): “RESEARCH ON FUZZY COMPREHENSIVE EVALUATION OF R&D STAFF BASED ON COMPETENCY MODEL AND CASE ANALYSIS”. In Information Management, Innovation Management and Industrial Engineering, 2009 International Conference (Vol. 3, pgs. 133-136).
KANER, S.; LIND, L.; TOLDI, C.; FISK, S.; BERGER, D. (2007): “FACILITATOR´S GUIDE TO PARTICIPATORY DECISION-MAKING”. Segunda Edición. Wiley. United States for America.
KEENEY, R. L.; RAIFFA, H. (1993): “DECISIONS WITH MULTIPLE OBJECTIVES: PREFERENCES AND VALUE TRADE-OFFS”. Cambridge university press.
KELLY, G. (1955): “THE PSYCHOLOGY OF PERSONAL CONSTRUCTS”. Vol. 1: “A THEORY OF PERSONALITY”. Vol. 2: “CLINICAL DIAGNOSIS AND PSYCHOTHERAPY”. New York. Norton.
KELEMENIS, A.; ERGAZAKIS, K.; ASKOUNIS, D. (2011): “SUPPORT MANAGERS? SELECTION USING AN EXTENSION OF FUZZY TOPSIS”. Expert Systems with Applications – Vol 38 - pgs. 2774-2782.
LIN, H. F.; LEE, H. S.; WANG, D. W. (2009): “EVALUATION OF FACTORS INFLUENCING KNOWLEDGE SHARING BASED ON A FUZZY AHP APPROACH”. Journal of Information Science – Vol 35 - pgs. 25-44.
MINGERS, J.; ROSENHEAD, J. (2004): “ANÁLISIS RACIONAL REESTUDIADO PARA UN MUNDO PROBLEMÁTICO: MÉTODOS PARA ESTRUCTURAR PROBLEMAS EN CONDICIONES DE COMPLEJIDAD, INCERTIDUMBRE Y CONFLICTO”. Instituto Venezolano de Planificación, España.
MINGERS, J.; BROCKLESBY, J. (1997): “MILTIMETHODOLOGY: TOWARDS A FRAMEWORK FOR MIXING METHODOLOGIES”. Omega – Vol. 25 – Nro. 5 – pgs. 489–509.
MINGERS, J. (2000): “VARIETY IS THE SPICE OF LIFE: COMBINING SOFT AND HARD OR/MS METHODS”. International Transactions in Operational Research – Vol 7 – Nro. 6 – pgs. 673-691.
MINGERS, J.; GILL, A. (Eds.). (1997): “MULTIMETHODOLOGY: TOWARDS THEORY AND PRACTICE AND MIXING AND MATCHING METHODOLOGIES”. John Wiley & Sons Incorporated.
RAHMAN, M.; GOVINDARAJULU, Z. (1997): “A MODIFICATION OF THE TEST OF SHAPIRO AND WILK FOR NORMALITY”. Journal of Applied Statistics – Vol. 24 – pgs. 219-2363
SAFARZADEGAN GILAN, S.; SEBT, M. H.; SHAHHOSSEINI, V. (2012): “COMPUTING WITH WORDS FOR HIERARCHICAL COMPETENCY BASED SELECTION OF PERSONNEL IN CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES-2. Applied Soft Computing – Vol 12 – pgs. 860-871.
SHAHHOSSEINI, V.; SEBT, M. H. (2011): “COMPETENCY-BASED SELECTION AND ASSIGNMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES TO CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS”. Scientia Iranica – Vol 18 – pgs. 163-180.
SORENSEN, L.; VIDAL R. (2003): “THE ANATOMY OF SOFT APPROACHES”. Pesquisa Operacional- Vol 24 – pgs.173-188.
TERVONEN, T.; FIGUEIRA, J. R. (2008): “A SURVEY ON STOCHASTIC MULTICRITERIA ACCEPTABILITY ANALYSIS METHODS”. Journal of Multicriteria Decision Analysis – Vol 15 -12 – pgs. 1-14.
TROVATO G.; PACHECO L. (2013): “EXPLORACIÓN DE TENDENCIAS EN ESTRUCTURACIÓN DE PROBLEMAS MULTICRITERIO”. Revista Escuela de Perfeccionamiento en Investigación Operativa (EPIO) – Vol 34 - pgs. 91-108.
VALQUI (2006): “OPERATIONAL RESEARCH: A MULTIDISCIPLINARY FIELD”. Pesquisa Operacional – Vol. 26 - pgs.69-90.
ZANAZZI, J.; GOMES, L. (2009): “LA BÚSQUEDA DE ACUERDOS EN EQUIPOS DE TRABAJO: EL MÉTODO DECISIÓN CON REDUCCIÓN DE LA VARIABILIDAD (DRV)”. Revista Pesquisa Operacional – Vol 29 - pgs. 195 - 221.
ZANAZZI, J.; DIMITROFF, M.; PONTELLI, D.; PEDROTI, B. (2013): “MÉTODOS PARA TOMAR DECISIONES EN GRUPO. COMPARACIÓN ENTRE PROCESOS DRV Y SMAA”. Revista Escuela de Perfeccionamiento en Investigación Operativa (EPIO) – Vol. 34 - pgs. 45 - 61.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Atribución — Usted debe dar crédito de manera adecuada, brindar un enlace a la licencia, e indicar si se han realizado cambios. Puede hacerlo en cualquier forma razonable, pero no de forma tal que sugiera que usted o su uso tienen el apoyo de la licenciante.
NoComercial — Usted no puede hacer uso del material con propósitos comerciales.
CompartirIgual — Si remezcla, transforma o crea a partir del material, debe distribuir su contribución bajo la misma licencia del original.
